This question always comes up and while I have a few minutes to spare I'd like to go ahead and address it here. First, we are not at all against public or private schools, nor do we
homeschool for religious reasons. Although we are a Christian family, our religious beliefs held no barring for our decision to
homeschool, and as such we opted not to file under the religious exemption with the state of VA. Secondly I would like it said that Reams Road Elementary probably has some of the best teachers there are and even though we no longer have children in the school we do still support them 100%!
So, why do we
homeschool then?? How did we get to this point? Well, about a year ago it all began. The stress put on teachers and therefore kids to perform well on
SOL's is ridiculous! I do not at all blame the teachers for this. The pressure is on them and sadly tied directly to their employment even. Their hands are tied and they must comply. The No Child Left Behind (
NCLB) bill was a great theory, and I'll admit that at the time I thought it sounded great too. But like a lot of things in life, what sounds great in theory is horrifying in practice! That is certainly the case with
NCLB. The second half of the school year is almost entirely devoted to prepping for SOL testings. They begin these tests in 3rd grade and we had a bit of a nightmare with Roman in 3rd grade over these tests. He is a perfectionist that internals his "failures" as he sees them. I put quotes around "failures" because they are NOT failures, no one is perfect and it's okay not to
accel 100% in every area of life, but he has a hard time grasping that. He also suffers from anxiety, particularly test anxiety. He had bouts of stomach issue after stomach issue in 3rd grade working himself up to the point that he was throwing up regularly just over worrying about these stupid tests. And here's the kicker,
Roman's a naturally bright boy. He scored above 95% on all his test that year! But upon returning from Christmas break in 2010 we began seeing these signs again. A legitimate bout of the stomach flu had him out of school for 2 weeks and he fell behind a bit because of it and with the end of the 9 week period approaching he didn't have time to make up all the work and in February his report card came back with a C. You would have thought it was the end of the world. He was devastated! It was down hill pretty fast from there. My little perfectionist weighed himself so heavily and we began to have emotional breakdowns at home, and the stomach problems began to escalate quickly to the point of ulcers. No 10 year old should have to suffer from that!
Public schools, especially in today's market don't have the resources, time, or funding to deal with a child like him. An exceptionally bright, good child. He is gifted in math, excels in science and social studies, but only average in language arts, therefore not a potential candidate for any of the gifted programs available, as they are all or nothing. He suffered from boredom in some areas, especially math, which lead to sloppy work and signs of bad habits already forming. Roman needed to be able to exceed his grade level in math, and even in science and social studies, but remain on target for all areas of language arts and there is just no program in public schools to reach the full potential of a kid like him.
So with his self-induced stress and perfectionist issues, compounded by increasingly sloppy work attributed to boredom (legitimately attributed to boredom too as he would do these long detailed math problems correctly showing his work, but write down the wrong answer!), we faced yet a 3rd strike with the public school system..... economic cut backs! Now this too is not the fault of the school, but with teacher cutbacks they were already predicting significant class size increases for the following year, good programs were being cut out altogether and all the schools were losing funding. These 3 strikes are the foundation behind our reasons to
homeschool.
After 2
incredibly rough weeks that were to the point that Roman didn't even want to go to school anymore, we decided it would be in his best interest to take a break from public school and work on some of his stress and anxiety issues in a healthier environment for him. And so I did my research, filed the necessary paperwork on Friday, February 26, 2010 he went to school for the last time to say goodbye to his teacher and classmates. And it was the BEST thing we have ever done for him!
In fact we quickly identified several of his bigger problems. Determining without a doubt that he is gifted in math. He left school working in an
accelerated math program at roughly a 1st half 5
th grade level and 4 months later tested at a 1st half 10
th grade level! Giving him the tools to reach his potential for the first time in his life and we quickly saw him soar!
Through all this we made the decision to leave our 2 oldest girls in public school. Neither were having any serious issues at that point and both were doing well, or so we thought at least. But, it went so well with Roman being
homeschooled that we quickly realized how great it would be to have all the kids home! And so the decision was made and the paperwork for the 2010-2011 school year was filed for all 3 kids.
At that time Bethany had already begun to struggle heavily in reading and after working side by side with her Kindergarten teacher we still had no answers as to why. We continue to struggle with it today and still have no answers as to why she seems to have a block on learning where reading is concerned when she had been doing so well previously, but we know that James and I are her biggest advocates and will get to the bottom of it and over this hurdle! We have since realized that Hope was the quiet, polite, good kid that never gave anyone any trouble and never really had any expectations for. No one has ever challenged her. Her math skills were appalling and yet she was making mostly E's in math these last few years. She was a kid that would have slipped through the holes of
NCLB being good enough to get by and that is not at all what we want for her! She is beginning to finally soar in so many areas with homeschooling!
So in hindsight we did have some teaching issues with the school that we were not fully aware of until we began homeschooling, but the initial decision to
homeschool the girls was purely for our family benefits. And we do not at all regret the decision. It has made us closer as a family and afford us so many new opportunities that we did not have while the kids were in public school!
Why not private school?? For us, as a family of 6 living on a single income the cost to our standards of living would have been significantly impacted with private school. So really it was never an option for us. James was already an experienced stay at home dad with Katy still at home, so homeschooling was a natural transition for us that minimally (upfront curriculum and resource costs only) altered our financial state.
Homeschooling is not for everyone, but for us it has been an amazing adventure and probably the best thing we've ever done for our family!